The San Francisco Giants closed out their 2024 season on a disappointing note, falling to the St. Louis Cardinals and clinching their first losing record since 2017. The loss not only capped off a frustrating campaign but also sparked an outpouring of reactions from fans, many of whom voiced their dissatisfaction on social media and other platforms. After a promising start that had the team in contention, the Giants’ late-season collapse has left fans wondering what went wrong and what changes might be on the horizon.
Fans took to platforms like Twitter and Reddit to express their frustration, with many pointing fingers at inconsistent performances and questionable roster decisions. One recurring theme among the reactions was the team’s lack of offensive firepower, which has been a problem all season long. Despite strong individual performances from players like Wilmer Flores and J.D. Davis, the Giants were plagued by an inability to deliver in clutch situations. “It’s painful to watch the team come so close only to fall short over and over,” one fan lamented.
Criticism was also directed at the front office, especially concerning the team’s strategy during the trade deadline. The Giants made a few modest moves, like acquiring veteran Mark Canha, but refrained from making any blockbuster trades that could have bolstered their roster. As one disgruntled fan put it, “The front office played it too safe, and now we’re paying the price.” The sentiment reflects a growing impatience among fans who believe the team’s current strategy is not enough to compete in the highly competitive National League West.
On the managerial side, there were mixed reactions to how manager Bob Melvin handled the team down the stretch. Some fans felt that Melvin did the best he could with the talent at his disposal, while others criticized his lineups and bullpen management. “We can’t just blame the players,” one fan said. “Melvin made some questionable calls, and that cost us a few crucial games.” With Melvin only recently taking over, it remains to be seen whether he will be given more leeway to mold the team in his vision or if the front office will make additional changes.
There was also disappointment in the performance of some key players who were expected to deliver but ultimately fell short. Pitchers like Logan Webb and Alex Cobb, who were reliable early in the season, struggled with inconsistency in the second half. Meanwhile, the offensive slumps of Brandon Crawford and Thairo Estrada at critical moments left fans frustrated and wondering if it’s time for a major roster overhaul. “We need new blood,” another fan commented. “This core isn’t getting it done.”
Despite the frustration, a segment of the fanbase remains hopeful that this disappointing season will serve as a wake-up call for the organization. “Sometimes, you need a season like this to realize what’s missing,” one optimistic fan suggested. Many are now looking ahead to the offseason, eager to see if the Giants will make significant moves in free agency or explore trades to strengthen their roster.
In the end, the 2024 season may be remembered as a turning point for the franchise—whether that’s for better or for worse remains to be seen. With a fanbase that has grown accustomed to success, the pressure is on for the front office to respond decisively. The offseason will be crucial as the Giants look to retool and restore confidence in a team that, for much of the year, seemed capable of much more.
