The San Francisco Giants are heading into a crucial offseason with several key veterans set to hit free agency once the World Series concludes. Among these players, Blake Snell stands out as a major storyline. Though technically under contract through the 2025 season, Snell has an opt-out clause that he is widely expected to exercise, making him one of the most sought-after pitchers in the free agency market. After a stellar second half, in which he posted a 1.23 ERA over his last 14 starts, Snell has proven his value as a high-caliber pitcher. The Giants are likely to be in the bidding for his services, but the competition will be fierce.
Another veteran facing an uncertain future with the Giants is outfielder Michael Conforto. Conforto signed a two-year, $36 million deal but has the option to leave after this season. His performance has been solid but not spectacular, highlighted by a .237/.310/.452 line with 20 home runs and 66 RBIs. Conforto’s power numbers are respectable, but he has struggled to reach base at his usual rate, a potential red flag for interested teams. Despite this, his ability to hit well on the road—where he recorded 17 of his 20 home runs—will likely attract suitors looking for a reliable left-handed bat.
Mark Canha, another veteran outfielder, finds himself in a similar situation. Acquired midseason, Canha provided steady production, slashing .288/.376/.329 in limited at-bats. However, his lack of power—no home runs in 85 plate appearances—raises questions about his long-term value. While Canha remains a versatile option defensively and a disciplined hitter, the Giants may opt to pursue younger players with a higher ceiling, making his return less likely. Canha’s local ties and connections to both manager Bob Melvin and president Farhan Zaidi could lead to a reunion, but only on a low-risk deal.
Curt Casali, a backup catcher for the Giants, represents a more straightforward decision. Brought back midseason to fill a void, Casali did not provide much offensively, and his defensive metrics show he is no longer a standout behind the plate. Still, his reputation as a pitcher-friendly catcher might earn him a minor league deal if the Giants want to retain him as depth. Given his experience and knowledge of the game, it would not be surprising to see Casali transition into a coaching role in the near future.
Another player likely on his way out is Donovan Walton. Walton was re-added to the roster late in the season but received limited playing time, tallying just two hits, including a home run, in 20 at-bats. The decision to bring him back puzzled many, as it took opportunities away from younger players who could have benefited from more experience. Walton’s stint with the Giants seems like a short-term solution rather than a long-term investment, making it unlikely that he will be part of the team’s future plans.
The Giants are at a crossroads as they decide how to handle these free agents. Blake Snell’s situation will be the most closely watched, given his potential to command a high-value contract. Conforto and Canha are also intriguing cases, as they offer solid production but may not fit the Giants’ long-term vision. For Casali and Walton, the decisions are less complicated, as they are more suited for minor roles or could potentially retire.
Overall, the Giants’ offseason strategy will reveal whether they are looking to build around veteran talent or focus on a younger, more dynamic roster. Retaining Snell could be a statement of intent, but losing key contributors like Conforto and Canha could signify a shift toward a rebuild. The front office’s handling of this free agent class will set the tone for the upcoming season and beyond, leaving fans eager to see how the roster shapes up.
With free agency looming, the Giants will have to weigh their options carefully. Whether they choose to retain some of their veteran talent or let them walk in favor of new acquisitions, their choices will undoubtedly shape the franchise’s direction heading into the 2025 season.
